Keepsafe vs Private Photo Vault

These are the two most-rated vault apps on the App Store, made by two unrelated companies, and on Google Play they are both titled Private Photo Vault. Half the people typing this comparison are trying to find out whether they are the same app. They are not, and the differences are the useful kind: where your photos live, who can let you back in, and what each company puts on record.

Short answer

They are different apps from different companies. Keepsafe (Keepsafe Software) is a cloud vault: an email account, a backup of 200 items free or 10,000 on Premium, sync between devices, and by its own account not a zero-knowledge design, so Keepsafe holds the backup and an email code can reset your PIN. Private Photo Vault (Legendary Software Labs) works offline with no account by default, and its optional Cloud Vault encrypts on the phone with a password the company says it cannot recover; its local PIN, however, can still be recovered by email. Both are subscriptions with ads in the free version, both have a fake PIN and break-in alerts on Premium. Keepsafe is $9.99 a month or $23.99 a year in the US; Private Photo Vault lists purchases from $6.99 to $39.99 without stating billing periods.

On this page

Keepsafe vs Private Photo Vault, side by side

Facts from each app's Google Play listing and Data safety section and US App Store listing, read 9 November 2026, and from each vendor's own help pages and website, linked in the sections below.

Keepsafe
Private Photo Vault
Where your photos live
On the phone
✓
✓
Account needed
Email address
No, unless you use Cloud Vault
Cloud copy
Private Cloud, 200 items free, 10,000 on Premium
Cloud Vault, Premium, up to 50 GB
Can the company read the cloud copy
Not designed as zero-knowledge, by its own account
No, per the vendor: encrypted on the phone first
Sync between devices
✓
With Cloud Vault
Encryption and research
Cipher named
256-bit AES
AES
Where the local key comes from
Not published
Keychain, per 2019 to 2021 research
Published research
2015 IOActive, iOS
2014 Zdziarski, 2015 IOActive, 2019 to 2021 forensicmike, iOS
Independent test of today's build
✕
✕
Getting in and getting back in
Unlock with
PIN, pattern or fingerprint
PIN, pattern, password, fingerprint or Face ID
Face ID alone can be refused
Not stated
Yes, Face ID plus PIN option
Forgot the code
Email access code
Recovery email
Fake PIN decoy
Premium
Premium
Break-in alerts
Premium, photo
Premium, photo and location
Per-album lock
Premium
Premium
Money and data
Ads in the free version
✓
✓
US App Store items
$9.99 a month, $23.99 a year, $35.99 Cloud Hider
$6.99 to $39.99, billing period not shown
Google Play price range
$0.99 to $299.99 per item
$2.99 to $179.99 per item
Shared for advertising, per Data safety
Nothing
Device IDs
Location collected, per Data safety
Approximate
Approximate and precise, optional, for fraud prevention
Installs and rating on Google Play
50M+, 4.7 from 2.07M reviews
10M+, 4.8 from 238K reviews
App Store ratings (US)
386K at 4.7
1M at 4.8

Play shows a price range per item with no billing period. Keepsafe's Android listing is titled "Private Photo Vault - Keepsafe"; Legendary Software Labs' is "Private Photo Vault - Pic Safe".

Not the same app, and how to tell them apart

Keepsafe is made by Keepsafe Software, Inc. Private Photo Vault is made by Legendary Software Labs LLC, which says it has been protecting private photos since 2011. On the App Store the titles are different enough: Keepsafe's is "Secret Photo Vault: Keepsafe" and Legendary's is "Private Photo Vault - Pic Safe". On Google Play both start with the words Private Photo Vault, and Keepsafe's full title is "Private Photo Vault - Keepsafe".

The simple check is the developer name under the title. com.kii.safe is Keepsafe; com.enchantedcloud.photovault is Legendary's app, and that bundle name is the one that appears in the research record below. Reviews, teardowns and complaints about one are regularly attributed to the other, in both directions, so check the name before you believe a review.

Sources: Google Play: Private Photo Vault - Keepsafe, Google Play: Private Photo Vault - Pic Safe, App Store: Secret Photo Vault, Keepsafe (US), App Store: Private Photo Vault - Pic Safe (US), Private Photo Vault: home page and FAQ

Two clouds, two different promises

Both apps can keep a copy of your vault on the company's servers. The promises attached to those copies are not the same, and this is the biggest real difference between the two.

Keepsafe's cloud is the centre of the app. You sign up with an email address, the free tier backs up your first 200 items, Premium raises that to 10,000, and sync between devices follows from it. Keepsafe documents 256-bit AES encryption at rest and says it does not look at your content. Its help centre also says the app is not currently designed as a completely zero-knowledge app. Both statements can be true at once: the company does not read your photos, and the design does not make it impossible for it to.

Private Photo Vault's Cloud Vault is optional and Premium. The company says files are encrypted on your device with your own key before upload, that the Cloud Vault password is never sent to its servers, and that it cannot recover that password if you lose it. That is a zero-knowledge claim, and a stronger one than Keepsafe's. It also means a forgotten Cloud Vault password is a lost backup, which the company says plainly.

Neither claim has been independently tested on the current builds, and we have not tested them. These are the vendors' descriptions of their own designs.

Sources: Keepsafe Help: How does the Keepsafe backup work?, Keepsafe Help: How does Keepsafe protect my data?, Keepsafe Help: Can Keepsafe see any of my content?, Private Photo Vault: home page and FAQ, Private Photo Vault: How your private photos are protected

Who can get you back in

The password reset is the quickest way to understand a vault's design. If a company can get you back into your photos, the key is somewhere the company can reach, and your code is a lock on the door rather than the thing that scrambles the files.

Keepsafe's help centre describes an email access code that signs you in on a new device and lets you reset a forgotten PIN. Private Photo Vault's FAQ describes a recovery email for a forgotten passcode. On the phone, then, both apps can let you back in through your email, and both are therefore open to anyone who controls that email account. The difference is the cloud: Private Photo Vault's Cloud Vault password has no reset, by design, while Keepsafe's cloud is reached through the same account the email code opens.

The published research points the same way for the local key. In 2014 Jonathan Zdziarski found Private Photo Vault storing photos unencrypted; by 2019 a forensics blogger found AES in use but the key in the iOS Keychain rather than derived from the PIN, which he confirmed again in 2021. IOActive's 2015 survey of iOS vaults covered both apps. That research describes the versions tested, not today's; it is also the only public evidence there is.

A vault whose key lives in the Keychain, or on a server, protects you against a lost phone and a person scrolling through it. It does not protect you against the company, a court order to the company, or anyone with your email. Whether that matters depends on what you are keeping.

Sources: Keepsafe Help: Can Keepsafe see any of my content?, Private Photo Vault: FAQ, Jonathan Zdziarski: Private Photo Vault, Not So Private (2014), IOActive: Breaking into and Reverse Engineering iOS Photo Vaults (2015), forensicmike1: iOS photo vault app still pwnable in 2019, updated 2021

What each one is actually good at

Keepsafe: the most used, with sync that just works
50M+ installs on Google Play and 386,000 App Store ratings. A cloud copy without thinking about it, sync across phones and tablets, Safe Send photos that disappear 20 seconds after they are seen, and a face-down lock. Premium adds Album Lock, Break-In Alerts, Fake PIN, Space Saver and Trash recovery, and removes ads.
Private Photo Vault: offline by default, with a cloud it says it cannot read
No account needed for the local vault. Unlock with a PIN, pattern, alphanumeric password, fingerprint or Face ID, with an option to require Face ID and the PIN together so a face alone is not enough. Premium adds Album Lock, Break-In Alerts with photo and location, Fake PIN, Cloud Vault up to 50 GB, Space Saver, custom covers and no ads. A million App Store ratings at 4.8.

Sources: Google Play: Private Photo Vault - Keepsafe, App Store: Secret Photo Vault, Keepsafe (US), Google Play: Private Photo Vault - Pic Safe, Private Photo Vault: home page and FAQ, App Store: Private Photo Vault - Pic Safe (US)

What each one costs, and how

Both are free to install with ads, and both sell Premium through in-app purchases. Keepsafe's US App Store listing shows a yearly Premium at $23.99 and a monthly at $9.99, plus a $35.99 Cloud Hider item. Its help centre explains that when a subscription lapses, your items stay in the app but the cloud backup shrinks to the free limit of 200. Over five years, Keepsafe Premium comes to about $120.

Private Photo Vault's US listing shows items named Upgrade and Premium from $6.99 to $39.99 with no billing period beside them, so you learn what a price buys at checkout. The company's FAQ says that if Premium expires, photos in the app stay accessible but the Cloud Backup is deleted, which makes it important to download Space Saver originals before letting it lapse.

On Google Play, both listings show a range per item and nothing else: $0.99 to $299.99 for Keepsafe, $2.99 to $179.99 for Private Photo Vault.

Sources: App Store: Secret Photo Vault, Keepsafe (US), Keepsafe Help: What to expect when my subscription expires, App Store: Private Photo Vault - Pic Safe (US), Private Photo Vault: FAQ, Google Play: Private Photo Vault - Keepsafe, Google Play: Private Photo Vault - Pic Safe

What the Data safety sections say

Google Play's Data safety section is written by the developer, so it is a statement of what each company is willing to put on record rather than a test. Read that way, the two are different in an instructive direction.

Keepsafe declares that nothing is shared for advertising, but that crash logs, diagnostics, app interactions, device IDs, user IDs and purchase history are shared with other companies for analytics. It declares collecting your name, email address, user IDs, photos and videos, files and documents, purchase history, approximate location, app interactions and installed apps. That is consistent with an app built around an account and a cloud.

Private Photo Vault declares that device IDs are shared for analytics and advertising, which is how the free version with ads pays for itself. It declares collecting crash logs, photos and videos, device IDs, app interactions, user IDs, and both approximate and precise location, the location marked optional and for fraud prevention, security and compliance, which fits a break-in alert that records where the attempt happened. It does not declare collecting your name or email.

Both say data is encrypted in transit and that you can request deletion.

Sources: Data safety: Keepsafe, Data safety: Private Photo Vault

Pick by what worries you

Losing the phone
Either, as long as backup is on. Keepsafe does it by default with an account; Private Photo Vault needs Premium and a Cloud Vault password you must not lose.
The company behind the app
Private Photo Vault, because its cloud is encrypted before upload with a password it says it never receives, and the local vault needs no account at all. Keepsafe says itself that it is not a zero-knowledge design.
Someone with access to your email
Neither is strong here. Both describe recovering a forgotten code through email. Use a vault whose key comes only from your code, or treat your email account's security as part of your vault's.
Someone who knows your phone passcode
Either. Both have their own lock. In Private Photo Vault, turn on the Face ID plus PIN option, so a glance at your face is not enough.
Ads and tracking in the free tier
Keepsafe declares nothing shared for advertising; Private Photo Vault declares device IDs. Paying for either removes the ads.
A tidy gallery and nothing more
Save the money. The iPhone Hidden album and Google Photos Locked Folder are free and already on your phone.

A third design, which is ours

We make AlterVault, so read this section as the maker's view. It fits neither column above, which is the only reason it is here.

There is no account, no cloud and no server. The key that seals your files is derived from your code with Argon2id, and the code is never stored, so there is no email route back in for anyone, including us. A 12-word phrase you write down, and a backup file you keep, are the only ways back. Like both apps' fake PIN, it has a second gallery, but it opens with a shake instead of a second code, so nobody watches you type anything. It costs $24.99 once, with 10 items free and no ads.

Where both of these apps beat it: no cloud and no sync, so losing the phone without a backup file means losing the vault; the code is six digits with no password option, which matters if someone copies your backup file; no fingerprint or Face ID unlock; no break-in photo. The source is not published and there is no outside audit, so its cipher, XChaCha20-Poly1305, is our word in the same way AES is theirs. The app sends anonymous usage events and a purchase check, never your photos, file names or code.

Switching from one to the other

Deleting a vault app removes what is stored in it, so the old app comes off last, after you have counted everything in the new one.

  1. Pause cloud photo backup

    Exported files land in your gallery unencrypted. If iCloud Photos or Google Photos backup is on, they upload within minutes. Turn it off until the plain copies are gone.

  2. Bring originals back first

    If you use Space Saver in either app, the full-size originals are in the cloud. Download them to the app while your subscription is active. Private Photo Vault says its cloud backup is deleted when Premium lapses.

  3. Export in batches

    Album by album, from the old app's own export, so a failure is easy to spot. Count what arrives.

  4. Import into the new vault

    Count again, album by album, and let the new app delete the originals if it offers to.

  5. Clear every plain copy

    The gallery, then Recently Deleted or Trash. Then turn cloud backup back on.

  6. Cancel, then delete

    A subscription is cancelled in the App Store or Google Play subscriptions screen, not by deleting the app or the account. Delete the old app only after the new one holds everything.

Sources: Keepsafe Help: What to expect when my subscription expires, Private Photo Vault: FAQ

Questions

Is Keepsafe the same as Private Photo Vault?

No. Keepsafe is made by Keepsafe Software and Private Photo Vault by Legendary Software Labs. The confusion comes from Google Play, where Keepsafe's listing is titled "Private Photo Vault - Keepsafe" and Legendary's is "Private Photo Vault - Pic Safe". Check the developer name under the title.

Which is safer, Keepsafe or Private Photo Vault?

For the cloud copy, Private Photo Vault makes the stronger claim: it says Cloud Vault files are encrypted on the phone with a password it never receives, while Keepsafe says its app is not a zero-knowledge design. On the phone, both can recover a forgotten code by email, so both depend on your email account's security. Neither has a public independent test of its current build.

Can Keepsafe see my photos?

Keepsafe says it does not look at your content and that items are encrypted with 256-bit AES at rest. It also says the app is not designed as a completely zero-knowledge app, so the design does not rule it out the way a key only you hold would. Its Data safety section declares photos and videos as data collected.

Can Private Photo Vault see my photos?

The company says no: on-device files use AES, and Cloud Vault files are encrypted on your device before upload with a password that is never sent to its servers. It also says it cannot recover that password. Its Data safety section declares photos and videos as optional data collected, which is how Play describes an app that handles them.

Which is cheaper, Keepsafe or Private Photo Vault?

Keepsafe Premium is $9.99 a month or $23.99 a year on the US App Store, about $120 over five years. Private Photo Vault lists purchases from $6.99 to $39.99 without showing billing periods, so compare at checkout. Both are free with ads if you never pay.

What happens if I forget my PIN?

Both apps describe an email route back in: Keepsafe sends an access code to the account email, and Private Photo Vault uses a recovery email for the passcode. A forgotten Private Photo Vault Cloud Vault password is different: the company says it cannot recover it.

Do Keepsafe and Private Photo Vault have a fake PIN?

Yes, both on Premium. Each opens a second, harmless vault when you type a second PIN at the lock screen. Both also offer break-in alerts on Premium; Private Photo Vault's records a photo and the location.

What happens to my cloud backup if I stop paying?

Keepsafe says your items stay in the app and the cloud backup shrinks to the free limit of 200 items. Private Photo Vault says photos in the app stay accessible but the Cloud Backup is deleted, so download any Space Saver originals before Premium lapses.

The third design: a key only your code makes

No account. Your photos stay on your phone.